Why the founder of Caddix Cleats trusts his gut instinct on product decisions and NFL controversies
Caddix cleats co-founder Jack Rasmussen repeatedly trusted his gut instinct on decisions ranging from how to respond to an NFL fine to offering a stranger a job on the spot.
Founder Brew is our twice-weekly newsletter covering how great ideas and entrepreneurial spirit grow into real businesses. We examine what it takes to build, the tradeoffs founders face, and what keeps them going.
FB
The NFL had just issued a $11,941 fine against Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams for wearing Caddix cleats during a game when the footwear company’s co-founder and CEO, Jack Rasmussen, got a random LinkedIn message.
The LinkedIn cold pitch suggested Rasmussen run billboards in the Second City blasting support for Williams. Rasmussen, intrigued by the idea, took a 10-minute walk to clear his head and consider what taking out a giant ad would mean for him and the company. He had to think about questions of defamation, brand recognition, and whether the company could even afford it.
“A 10-minute walk is not a long time to think about a decision like that,” Rasmussen told Founder Brew. “But it is for me, so that’s my process.” He decided to go for it.
Rasmussen said going with your gut instinct is the best decision for founders. He believes too much advice, or solely focusing on analytics and metrics, can inundate founders, lead them down the wrong path, or simply get in the way of unexpected opportunities.
Caddix, with its signature cleats featuring what the company describes as “movable studs” to prevent injuries, is in the process of raising a Series A round of funding and has a crop of athlete-investors including Super Bowl MVP Joe Flacco and wide receiver Ja’Kobi Lane.
Rasmussen’s pursuit of footwear protecting an athlete’s ankle and joint health has been scrappy from the beginning.
“We try to think for the future here at Caddix,“ he said. “But, the best things that happen to us are the ones that we don’t really account for until it’s like a minute away.”
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Did you have any models for entrepreneurship? How did you know how to start?
No, I didn’t, and I really wish I did. I probably would have saved a ton of time. I tell my team I only know a few things: I know what’s right. I know what’s wrong. I know what makes sense; and everything other than that I just can’t speculate on. Honestly. At the time, what made sense was to just bug everybody for information, make sketchy cleats in my garage, and just go for it.
I’ve never read a business book in my life to this day. I really haven’t. I don’t know much about conventional business and how to approach a marketing campaign or intellectual property. I just am a doer, which is great in some ways, but also not in a lot of other ways.
The sketchy cleats, I want to hear more about that. What did you start building, and how did the idea change as you were testing?
If you combine quick hardening caulk and blue dish soap—it has to be blue for some reason. Don’t ask me why—it creates this very transparent rubber substance that you can manipulate. So what I did was I cut out a cleat sole and I put it in this mold of this mystery material and let it harden. And it was this clear rubbery thing that I could glue to the bottom of a cleat, and that whole thing flexed. Our first idea was the whole shoe itself would flex instead of the studs.
That was the first one we made, and then [we started] taking other people’s cleats and ripping them apart and putting our studs when we found out the studs were going to work more than the shoe sold. That was part of the process. The first patent we wrote was about a shoe sole, and now our studs are proprietary, obviously. But it transformed over a number of years [and] a number of different ways.
How’d you figure out to start focusing on the studs?
We got with a team in Portland, Oregon called i-generator, and these guys are the best…I approached them with my idea right before Covid, and they said, “Look, this shoe sole concept is sound, but it’s not practical from a manufacturing standpoint.” And we all kind of put our heads together, and someone suggested, “Let’s put it in the studs.” And I was like, “All right,” because I didn’t want to make cleats necessarily, I wanted to make shoes that could alleviate injury.
Movement needs to happen at the ground level. If the sole itself can’t move, if the turf or grass doesn’t move, the athlete has to move, and it’s usually under the load of excessive force in your ligaments. Cleats were inherently designed to grab the ground and increase traction, but too much traction equates to injurious loads. I know traction is responsible for performance, but at some point, it becomes dangerous for us.
The stud just made sense because it’s kind of the junction point between the foot and the ground.
Did anyone tell you not to do this, to give up?
Oh totally, absolutely. Dozens and dozens of people…I was emailing this surgeon years ago and he was very helpful with my approach to all this when I was a 19-year-old kid. I’ll never forget his last email which was like, “Hey man, I want you to know that if you figure this out, you figured out the Mount Everest of footwear.” I’ll never forget that…That was certainly like, “Oh ok, this is actually worth the time and the hard work.”
Who were the most important people in your orbit through these failures and successes?
My family. My family watched me do this since I was 19. They’ve always pushed me and supported me in various ways. But my friends were great in college, too. My friends saw what I was building, and actually some of my friends invested in Caddix when they were in college,
Then the team in Oregon, i-generator, I won’t do enough good in my lifetime to deserve a team like that working with Caddix. They’ve been instrumental. They have dumbed things down so my adolescent brain can comprehend certain things, and they’ve sacrificed time and evenings and some weekends. They’ve been huge.
What’s unconventional about Caddix?
We approach things and we react and respond, as opposed to structuring an approach to traditional marketing campaigns and all those things they tell you in business school to do and look far ahead for the future.
We try to think for the future here at Caddix, but the best things that happen to us are the ones that we don’t really account for until it’s like a minute away…We want to plan the future, but we’re just running so fast right now and so thin, which is fun. I like it that way. I like being lean and nimble. But our marketing is different. It looks different. It reads different…There’s a dirt bike group in Baltimore. It goes to the streets, and we had them hold the cleats up and do wheelies in the street. That has nothing to do with sports, you know what I mean? But it’s just cool. I think it’s that strategic confusion. It’s like, “Okay, why does this cleat company have a bunch of guys on dirt bikes in Baltimore holding cleats?”
What intuition guides you through that “strategic confusion”? What’s the gut feeling you have about when it’s the right opportunity?
It’s really hard to quantify and measure a gut feeling because they happen so sporadically and so instantly. It’s like: This is the right thing to do. This isn’t.
If you take a step back and look at a gut feeling and analyze it on a different timeline, how do I feel right now? How will I feel if I say yes in 10 days? How will I feel if I say no in 10 days, or 30 days, or a year? Is it going to impact the next month? Is it going to impact the next year? Is it going to alter our way we’re seeing in retailers? Is it going to affect our projections? Is it going to affect our current inventory?
Those are the kind of things that I try to be more conventional at, and less sporadic in my decision making. I think I fall victim to being a bit impetuous sometimes, which is a good thing. But I think taking a step back, taking a deep breath, and realizing what a decision based off a gut reaction could do to you, your employees, your business, and the future is is very important to to kind of dive into.
What advice do you have for other founders?
Sometimes you can look at analytics and metrics all you want, and people who are in this field who are deemed veterans can only give you so much advice, right? Everything is so relative to where you are at the stage of your venture; what you’re approaching the market trying to go into, the funding you do or don’t have. I think it’s so specific and relative.
Be careful who you receive advice from…If you ask them a question, they’ll give you advice on their goal, not yours. I think there needs to be a bit of caution when you hear advice from somebody, and how much it’s worth to you.